Old Town, Fort Collins

Old Town Fort Collins is the neighborhood that every other Fort Collins neighborhood gets compared to — and usually comes up short. After five decades of watching this market, I can tell you the fundamentals here are as strong as I've ever seen them, and the 7.8% price bump over the last 90 days confirms what buyers are already figuring out on their own. If you're serious about Old Town, you need to move with a plan, because 27 days on market means hesitation costs you.

Market Snapshot

At a median price of $458,485 and $228 per square foot, Old Town is priced at a premium relative to most of Fort Collins — and it earns it. That price point reflects the walkability, the historic stock, and the simple fact that you can't manufacture more land inside the original city grid. When I started in this business, Old Town was undervalued and overlooked. That era is long gone.

The 7.8% price appreciation over just 90 days is a number worth sitting with. That's not an annual figure — that's a single quarter. With only 43 active listings and just 9 new listings hitting the market in the last 30 days, supply is genuinely tight. Buyers who are waiting for a price correction in this specific submarket are likely going to wait a long time.

At 27 average days on market, well-priced homes are moving. That said, I do see some listings sitting longer when sellers or their agents misprice — usually overreaching on a remodel or addition that the appraisers won't fully support. The market is strong but not forgiving of wishful pricing.

Who Lives Here

Old Town draws a genuinely mixed demographic that you don't find in many neighborhoods at this price point. You've got long-term Fort Collins families who bought in the 80s and 90s and have no intention of leaving, alongside younger professionals — often CSU faculty, tech workers, or downtown business owners — who are willing to pay a premium to walk to work and eliminate a car payment.

CSU graduate students and young faculty gravitate toward the blocks closest to campus, particularly around Remington Street and Whedbee Street. Empty nesters from the suburbs are increasingly trading their Harmony Road square footage for a smaller Old Town bungalow where they can actually use their neighborhood rather than just park in it.

Investors — both local and out-of-state — are also present, particularly chasing short-term rental plays near the Downtown Entertainment District on College Avenue and Mountain Avenue. That's worth knowing if you're a buyer who cares about neighborhood stability, because the short-term rental density on some blocks is higher than it looks at first glance.

Neighborhood Character

Old Town is essentially Fort Collins' original street grid, radiating out from Old Town Square at College Avenue and Mountain Avenue. The architecture is honest about its age — Craftsman bungalows on Mathews Street, Victorian two-stories on Remington, early 20th-century foursquares on Peterson Street. These aren't cookie-cutter houses, and that's the point. Every block has its own personality.

The drawbacks are real and worth naming. Parking is genuinely difficult, especially east of College Avenue on weekends when the bars and restaurants fill up. Some of the alleys behind the older lots are in rough shape. Traffic on College Avenue itself is constant and loud if you're within a block of it. And while the tree canopy along streets like Oak Street and Magnolia Street is beautiful, those mature trees also mean root damage to older infrastructure.

What makes it irreplaceable is the walkability score — you can realistically live car-light here. Odell Brewing, Choice City Butcher, the Lincoln Center, Washington's Sports Bar, the old Trimble Court galleries, the Fort Collins Museum of Discovery on Olive Street — these are all walkable. The Poudre River Trail access at Lee Martinez Park is a short ride north. That's a lifestyle you cannot replicate in any other Fort Collins zip code.

Zoning & Development

Most of the residential blocks in Old Town fall under the City of Fort Collins' Neighborhood Conservation Low Density (NCL) or Neighborhood Conservation Medium Density (NCM) zones, with some parcels near Canyon Avenue and Mulberry Street carrying different designations. These zones limit what you can do, but they're also exactly why Old Town looks the way it does. The city has been deliberate about protecting the historic character, and the Landmark Preservation Commission has real teeth.

ADU potential exists but comes with conditions. The city has loosened ADU rules in recent years, and carriage houses behind Old Town lots are increasingly being converted or newly permitted. If you're buying a larger lot — anything over 6,000 square feet — have a conversation about ADU viability before you close, not after. For investors or buyers who want to offset carrying costs, an accessory unit can pencil out well given the rental demand near CSU. Just budget for the permitting timeline, which in Fort Collins can run longer than buyers expect.

Commute & Connectivity

If you work downtown Fort Collins, your commute is a walk or a five-minute bike ride. That's not hyperbole — that's the math of the street grid. CSU's main campus is about 10 minutes on foot from the center of Old Town, or under 5 minutes by bike via the Poudre Trail connectors. For a commuter city, that's as good as it gets in Northern Colorado.

For regional commuters, the picture is more realistic. Greeley is roughly 35-40 minutes east on US-34 depending on traffic through Loveland. Denver is about 65-70 minutes south on I-25 under normal conditions — budget 90 minutes for morning rush into downtown Denver. DIA from Old Town runs 80-90 minutes. I-25 access from Old Town means heading south on College or east to Mulberry, neither of which is fast at peak hours. If you're commuting to Denver daily, Old Town is livable but you'll feel it.

Schools & Amenities

The Poudre School District serves Old Town, and the schools feeding this neighborhood include Lincoln Middle School on Remington Street and Fort Collins High School on Laporte Avenue. Lincoln has a solid reputation for its arts integration and bilingual programming. Fort Collins High is a large comprehensive school — it has strong AP offerings and competitive athletics, though the size means it's not for every kid. For elementary, Irish Elementary and Putnam Elementary both serve portions of Old Town and are generally well-regarded by families in the area.

Amenities in and around Old Town are extensive by any standard. Grocery access is honest rather than glamorous — a Whole Foods on South College and a King Soopers on Riverside are your closest full-service options, neither of which is walkable. The Farmer's Market on Saturdays near Old Town Square fills some of that gap in warmer months. For healthcare, UCHealth's Harmony campus and Banner Health's McKee facility in Loveland are your main options, both a 15-20 minute drive. Parks are abundant — City Park on Mulberry is the largest green space nearby and hosts Fort Collins' signature summer events.

The Investment Angle

Old Town is not a cash-flow neighborhood for traditional long-term rentals at these price points. At $458,000 median with today's interest rates, the numbers on a straight buy-and-hold rental are tight at best. Where investors are making money is in short-term rentals (where city regulations permit them), house hacking with ADUs, or buying underimproved properties and doing a proper renovation before selling into a supply-constrained market.

The appreciation story is compelling for patient equity investors. Old Town has consistently outperformed the broader Fort Collins market on price-per-square-foot gains over the decade I've tracked it closely, and the supply constraints are structural — you cannot build more Old Town. The 7.8% quarterly gain is exceptional, but even in flat years this submarket tends to hold value better than newer subdivisions. If you're buying with a 5-10 year horizon and you can tolerate thin initial cash flow, Old Town is one of the more defensible investments in Northern Colorado real estate.

Bottom Line

Old Town is the right move for buyers who prioritize walkability, architectural character, and long-term value over square footage and a garage. It makes the most sense for downtown professionals, empty nesters downsizing from the suburbs, and buyers with a 5-plus year time horizon who understand they're paying for land and location, not just a house. If you need four bedrooms and a three-car garage under $500,000, look at Fossil Lake or Rigden Farm — but if those trade-offs sound like losses rather than wins, Old Town is worth the premium.

Search Old Town Listings

Browse active listings in Old Town — updated daily from the IRES MLS.

View active listings in Old Town →